When I saw trailers for a Dune related mini-series in the fall, I thought it was time to reread the Dune series of books. So I went online to get the right order only to find that since I last read the Dune books, their number had increased greatly — there were another nine books! Fortunately my local library had all but one of the books I did not already have.
So more than six months later, I have finally gotten to the end of the series. I have come across other sci-fi books which are longer, those in the Dune series are not short reads. Most of them were over 400 pages and a few over 600.
The initial books were authored by Frank Herbert. His son, Brian Herbert and his co-author Kevin Anderson were responsible for the later books (which tell parts of the story before, after and in between the original six books.) The writing style between the two was significant. After this re-reading, I am totally puzzled why Dune was such a big hit. Page after page is a character thinking or talking about what they are thinking. It often felt like the Frank Herbert was pushing a philosophy of some sort on his readers. The other books stick to more normal story-telling principles. With one exception — it seemed like they were writing for a multi-year TV series. Books didn’t really end with a conclusion, but left the reader hanging for the next book / season.
As I recall from my schooling, fiction often requires a “suspension of disbelief”. Sci-fi tends to rely heavily on that. But some of the Dune stories and themes seriously pushed my abilities in that respect. For instance, the imperial family, the Corrinos, had been in charge of the empire for 10,000 years. Seriously? With all the palace intrigue along with normal issues of hereditary rule, that is a bit much to swallow. And I do not understand how a society with advanced space travel and related tech would be so inclined to no tech for just about everything else. Even allowing for their fear of machine intelligence which had once enslaved them, the extremes and inconsistencies were awkward at best. (And I do not understand why the machines would want a bunch of unruly organic human slaves when they also had the ability to have well behaved machine robots.)
Another direction I found my thoughts going I as read through the Dune series was the “compare and contrast” assignments from long ago classwork. So compare and contrast the Dune empire with that of Asimov’s Foundation and Empire series or else with the Empire of Star Wars. (And what is with the need for imperial government in a future society???)